A lanai pool is the best way to enjoy your outdoor space and stay protected from the environmental elements. Interested in pool enclosure options? Then, a screen enclosure will be best for you. The decision can be a little tricky because both have their own style, benefits, and costs.
Don’t get confused, you will be able to make a decision on which is better for you by the end of this blog, whether it’s a cozy lanai or functional pools with screen enclosures.
What Is a Pool Lanai?
A swimming pool lanai is a covered outdoor living space that is connected to your home. It has a roof and open sides. In Florida, pool lanais are popular, where you can relax and entertain guests as well, without any worries about the weather or bugs.
Structure and Design
- A lanai for pool has a solid roof with aluminum panels or shingles, supported by sturdy posts for stability.
- You can add screened sides if you want air flow and protection from bugs.
- You can have other features too, such as glass or vinyl windows. They can make your space more weather-protected.
- A lanai with a pool is designed to match your home’s architecture. It can feel like a natural extension of your living area.
Weather Protection
- Due to its solid roof design, A Florida pool lanai gives excellent weather protection.
- It can protect your area from rain, wind-blown debris, and bright sunlight.
- Your area will be cooler even during summer due to the shade.
- It won’t let you get wet during rain as well. You can enjoy the rain fully.
Cost and Installation
- It needs a bigger investment due to more materials and labor as compared to a screen enclosure.
- Costs depend on the roof design, size of the lanai, and the type of materials.
- The upfront cost is higher, but many homeowners consider it enhances property value.
- You must hire licensed contractors to install it. They make sure to use all local building codes and safety standards.
What Is a Screen Pool Enclosure?
A screen pool enclosure is a lightweight framing made from aluminum. It is fitted with mesh screens. The pool area is fully surrounded by it, and it keeps away insects and debris. It is airy and lets the sunlight in.
Structure and Design
- Made from durable screen enclosure materials like fiberglass or polyester mesh
- Supported by rust-resistant aluminum screen enclosure materials for low maintenance.
- Many modern builds use clear view screen enclosure panels for a more open, airy look
Weather Protection
- Wind-blown debris is less due to the shade.
- You can keep insects, leaves, and small animals out.
- Unlike a lanai, it won’t fully block heavy rain or strong sunlight.
Cost and Installation
- Generally more affordable than a lanai
- Cost depends on size, screen type, and frame material
- Installation of most screen enclosures is quick. Can be ready in just a few days.
- Maintenance, like fixing torn screens or cleaning the frame, is easy.
Key Differences Between Lanai and Screen Pool Enclosures
Lanai pool & screen pool enclosures serve different purposes. You can choose according to your requirements and what overall look you want for your pool area.
Design and Construction
- A lanai feels like a true extension of your home, with a solid roof and customizable walls
- An airy screen enclosure is designed specially for insect and debris control.
- lanais has more architectural flexibility and style options. You can customize both.
Weather Protection and Durability
- Lanais is perfect for maximum weather protection due to its strong roof.
- Screen enclosures provide more airflow and visibility; they are perfect for mild weather but do not work well in harsh conditions, though regular pool leak detection can help you avoid costly damage after storms.
- Durable screen enclosure materials can handle everyday wear, though not as much as a fully enclosed lanai, and proper upkeep, like knowing how to fix and prevent green pool water, keeps your pool area in top shape year-round.
Cost Comparison
- Screen enclosures are more budget-friendly upfront
- The property value is increased by Lanai.
- You have to choose a lanai and a screen enclosure according to your budget and your need for weather protection.
Pros and Cons of Lanai pool vs Screen Enclosure Pool
Both bring special advantages to Florida homes. You can take guidance from the advantages and challenges to determine which option is better for you, one that also matches your lifestyle, budget, and enjoyment.
Lanai Pros
- A lanai’s solid roof and enclosed design protect your pool area from heavy rain, sunlight debris. It makes your pool usable in all weather.
- Lanai is considered to be a valuable home improvement. Your property resale price will be increased, and it will make your home visually appealing.
- You can get protection from sunburn due to shade that keeps the space cooler as well..
- If you need more privacy, you can customize the lanai with windows and screens.
Lanai Cons
- It has a Higher installation cost due to the solid construction and high-quality materials as compared to a screen.
- A lot of structural work is involved in building a lanai; that’s why the completion time is longer than a screen enclosure.
- A permit is required to build a lanai, so the process might get long in order to get additional inspections or approvals.
Screen Enclosure Pros
- Screen enclosures are budget-friendly and ideal for those who want them at a low price.
- The mesh screening doesn’t let leaves, insects, and small animals into the pool, which reduces cleaning time.
- It doesn’t have a solid roof, so it allows natural light and fresh air to flow through. You can enjoy the outdoors and get protected from pests as well.
- They are lightweight and easy to install.
Screen Enclosure Cons
- It has Less weather protection, can’t protect you from heavy rain and strong winds like Lanai.
- Screens can tear and need replacement because, over time, exposure can weaken the screens.
- With mesh walls and an open feel, screen enclosures don’t provide privacy from neighbors or nearby streets.
Lanai vs Screen Pool Enclosure: Which is Right for You?
You have to see your requirements, like lifestyle and climate, before choosing the right option. The decision also depends on how frequently you use the pool. If you’re looking for a pool area that is like a living space and you want good protection from the weather, a lanai is the best option for you.
On the other hand, if you prefer an open, airy feel, better insect control, and want to be on a smaller budget, a screen enclosure is best.
Final Thoughts
Whether you choose a lanai or a screen pool enclosure, your outdoor living experience will improve significantly. And while these structures make your pool area enjoyable, keeping your pool clean and safe is just as important.
That’s where Aqua Pristine comes in! We provide professional pool repair and maintenance, along with cleaning services, so you can enjoy a sparkling pool all year long, without the hassle.
Areas We Serve
We proudly serve these locations in Florida:
Ready to keep your pool crystal clear? Contact Aqua Pristine today for expert pool cleaning and maintenance services you can trust!
FAQs
Which is better, a lanai or a screen enclosure?
Both have benefits and drawbacks; it depends on your choice and priority. If you need strong protection and a more roomy feeling, a lanai is better. Otherwise, if you need more affordable, airy, and easy-to-install, then a screen enclosure is perfect for you.
Which option do you think is ideal for homes in Florida?
If you want full year weather protection and extra shelter, then a lanai is best. If you want open views and air, then a screen enclosure is ideal.
Do both options prevent bugs?
Yes, both prevent insects from reaching your pool. The main difference is how much they protect you from the weather.
What is the approximate lifespan of lanai screens?
If you do proper care of them, they can last up to 7 to 15 years. You need to replace them before that time.
Why are lanais only popular in Florida?
Lanais are popular everywhere! But Florida’s warm weather, scorching sun, and regular rain make them especially loved here.